If goods arrive damaged, fail soon after purchase, do not match their description or never arrive, this guide helps you identify the likely remedy, estimate what you may recover and make a clear complaint to the retailer. It covers the Consumer Rights Act 2015, delivery responsibility, repair and replacement decisions, refunds, payment-provider escalation and the evidence to keep.
Overview
When you buy goods from a business as a consumer, the goods should generally be of satisfactory quality, fit for a particular purpose made known to the seller, and as described. These protections apply whether you bought in a shop, through a retailer’s website or through a marketplace, although you should first establish who the actual contracting trader is.
The retailer is normally responsible for putting the problem right. A manufacturer’s warranty can provide an additional route, but it does not usually remove your legal rights against the seller. If a product is faulty, damaged or misdescribed, the remedy may be a repair, replacement, price reduction or refund. If an order never arrives, the issue is usually a delivery breach rather than a faulty-goods claim.
| Problem or remedy | What it usually means | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Short-term right to reject | You may be able to reject faulty or misdescribed goods and request a refund within 30 days of delivery, subject to the circumstances. | Record the delivery date and explain the fault clearly. |
| Repair | The retailer may repair the goods where this is a reasonable way to resolve the problem. | The repair should be completed within a reasonable time and without significant inconvenience. |
| Replacement | You may request a replacement, although the retailer may be able to offer repair instead where the requested remedy is impossible or disproportionate. | Keep the original item and agree who pays return and delivery costs. |
| Price reduction | A partial refund may be appropriate if repair or replacement is unavailable, unsuccessful or would cause significant inconvenience. | Explain how the defect affects value or use and show how you calculated the amount. |
| Final right to reject | After an unsuccessful repair or replacement, you may be entitled to reject the goods or seek a price reduction. | Refund calculations and any permitted deduction can depend on the item and timing. |
| Failed delivery | The seller is generally responsible for getting the goods to you unless you arranged your own carrier outside the seller’s offered options. | Check the promised delivery date, tracking record and any safe-place instruction. |
How to estimate the remedy and amount
Use a simple decision sequence rather than asking for every remedy at once.
- Identify the contract. Write down the retailer, seller account, order number, item, price and purchase date. A marketplace may host an independent trader, so direct the complaint to the business named on the order or invoice.
- Classify the problem. Decide whether the goods are faulty, damaged in transit, not as described, unsuitable for a stated purpose or missing altogether. Include photographs, test results and the date you first noticed the problem.
- Check the timing. Count from delivery, not simply from the date you placed the order. If the goods were delivered in separate instalments, consider each item separately. The first 30 days are especially important because the short-term right to reject may be available.
- Choose a proportionate outcome. For a minor and easily corrected defect, repair or replacement may be practical. For a serious safety issue, a substantially different product or a failed repair, a refund or price reduction may be more suitable.
- Calculate the request. For a full rejection, start with the amount paid for the goods and any delivery charge that the law requires the retailer to repay. For a partial remedy, state the proposed reduction in pounds and explain the basis: reduced usefulness, missing features, cosmetic damage or the cost of an agreed remedy.
- Allow a reasonable response. Set a clear reply date in your complaint. Do not dispose of the item or pay for a repair yourself unless the retailer has agreed, because doing so may make the dispute harder to prove.
For a non-delivery, estimate the amount claimed as the purchase price plus any delivery charge that should be returned. Ask the retailer either to deliver by a specific reasonable date or to cancel and refund. If delivery by a particular date was essential and this was made clear before the contract, explain that point.
Inputs and assumptions
Before sending a complaint, create a short calculation sheet with these inputs:
- Purchase price: the amount paid for the goods, including any discounts or vouchers.
- Delivery charge: separate standard and express charges where relevant.
- Delivery date: the date the item came into your possession, or the promised date if it did not arrive.
- Fault date: when the problem was first noticed and whether it appeared immediately.
- Remedy history: dates of collection, repair, replacement and return, plus what happened afterwards.
- Additional loss: reasonable, evidenced costs that directly resulted from the problem. Avoid assuming that every inconvenience or consequential loss will automatically be recoverable.
- Payment method: card, finance, bank transfer, PayPal or another provider. The available escalation route depends on this detail.
Keep the assumptions visible. For example: “The item was delivered on 4 March; the defect was reported on 10 March; no repair has been attempted; I am requesting rejection within the short-term period.” If the retailer disputes when the fault arose, preserve the packaging, delivery photographs and any technical assessment. Within the first six months, the law may make it easier to argue that a lack of conformity was present at delivery, although the precise position depends on the goods and circumstances.
Complaint letter template
Subject: Order [number] – faulty, damaged or undelivered goods
“I bought [item] from you on [date] for £[amount]. It was delivered on [date] / has not arrived. The problem is: [clear description]. The goods do not meet the required standard because [fault, damage or mismatch]. I am requesting [refund, repair, replacement or price reduction]. Please confirm the next steps by [date]. If you require the item returned, please provide a prepaid method and confirm when the refund or replacement will be issued. I attach [photos, order confirmation, tracking and correspondence].”
Send the complaint to the retailer, not only to the manufacturer. If the retailer refuses or does not respond, consider a formal escalation, a card or payment-provider dispute and, where appropriate, a letter before action. Our guide to Section 75 and chargeback claims explains why those routes are separate from the retailer’s statutory obligations.
Worked examples
Example 1: Fault reported within 30 days
A £180 appliance arrives on 1 May and stops working on 8 May. The buyer has photographs, the order confirmation and no previous repair attempt. The starting calculation is £180 for the goods, plus any delivery charge that should be repaid. The buyer can ask to reject the item and should explain the fault, the delivery date and the requested collection or return method.
Example 2: Repair fails
A £420 laptop is repaired but develops the same fault shortly afterwards. The buyer records the original complaint, repair report and return dates. A second repair may be unreasonable if it causes significant inconvenience or is unlikely to resolve the issue. The buyer can ask for a replacement, a price reduction or final rejection, depending on the facts. The proposed amount should account for any legally permitted deduction and should not simply be described as “compensation”.
Example 3: Order never arrives
A £75 item was promised by 12 June but tracking shows no delivery. The buyer sends a written deadline and asks the retailer to deliver or refund. The calculation is the £75 purchase price plus the relevant delivery charge. A screenshot showing the promised date and tracking history is more useful than a general statement that the courier has lost the parcel.
If you paid by credit card, a Section 75 claim may sometimes provide an additional route for qualifying purchases. Chargeback is a payment-scheme process rather than the same legal remedy, and time limits or evidence requirements can apply. Contact the payment provider promptly while continuing to keep the retailer complaint record.
When to recalculate and what to do next
Revisit your calculation whenever a key input changes: the 30-day period approaches or expires, the retailer offers repair or replacement, a repair fails, a replacement is also defective, delivery eventually occurs, or the retailer makes a partial refund offer. Record the date of every event because the available remedy can change as the dispute progresses.
For online or other distance purchases, check the separate cancellation rules as well as faulty-goods rights. A cancellation period may exist even where the goods are not defective, but exceptions can apply, including for certain personalised, sealed or digital products. Do not confuse a change-of-mind return with a statutory claim that the goods were faulty or misdescribed.
If the retailer rejects your complaint, ask for the decision and reasons in writing. Check whether the seller belongs to an alternative dispute resolution scheme, and consider your payment provider if relevant. If the amount justifies court action, send a focused letter before action, attach the evidence list and state the remedy and calculation clearly. Our small claims pre-action guide and evidence bundle checklist can help with that next stage. Review this article annually and after relevant legal or official guidance changes, particularly the remedy periods, delivery rules and payment-dispute procedures.